Home → Locations → Neighborhoods → Fleming Island
Living in Fleming Island, FL
Clay County’s top shelf — the best public schools in the county, master-planned streets, and 4,092 veterans who already chose it.
Fleming Island at a Glance
- Single-family median: $475,000
- $210 per square foot
- Robert M. Paterson Elementary: 10/10
- CrimeGrade overall: A+
- 4,092 veterans
- Cost of living index: 85
The Fleming Island Market
The single-family median in Fleming Island is $475,000 (Q1 2026): $210 per square foot, 48 days on market, +1.1% year over year, and about 97% list-to-sale. The median listing is $489,000 (Realtor.com, Sep 2026), and median rent is $2,250 per month. This is a premium, low-turnover, master-planned market, with a thin Doctors Lake waterfront segment.
Resale: What Holds Value in Fleming Island
Clay County’s strongest public schools are the price floor here, backed by Eagle Harbor amenities — golf, pools and river access — and built-out scarcity. Cautions: 1990s stock hits the insurance wall, with 4-point and wind-mitigation inspections standard on pre-2002 homes; HOA + CDD fees raise carrying costs and must be priced into any comparison; and waterfront trades thin and slow, at 90–150 days.
Schools in Fleming Island
Fleming Island sits in the Clay County school district (district grade A). Robert M. Paterson Elementary rates 10/10, Fleming Island Elementary 9/10, and Thunderbolt Elementary 8/10. Fleming Island High School rates 7–8/10 with a Niche grade of A (fih.oneclay.net). Junior-high zoning varies by address — Lakeside Junior High, rated 7/10, serves part of the island.
Shopping, Food and Daily Life
Whitey’s Fish Camp has operated since 1963 on Doctors Lake — Clay County’s oldest restaurant — at Google 4.4 stars (about 11,380 reviews). Santioni’s Italian, with live piano, is the island’s date-night staple at TripAdvisor 4.6 stars (263 reviews). Village Square / Town Center retail, anchored by Publix, covers daily needs.
Cost of Living in Fleming Island
The cost of living index is 85 (BestNeighborhood). AreaVibes puts the cost of living 17% above the Florida average, with a livability score of 82. Property tax in ZIP 32003 runs about 1.14% effective (Ownwell) — the highest in Clay County, consistent with newer, higher-value stock. HOA + CDD fees stack on top of the tax bill in the planned communities. Run the numbers for a Fleming Island purchase with the affordability calculator.
Who Lives in Fleming Island
Median household income is $117,414 — the highest in the area — and the median age is 47. Some 48.3% of residents hold a bachelor’s degree or higher, and 85.2% of homes are owner-occupied. This is an affluent community of families and professionals; 44% of homes were built between 2000 and 2009.
Safety in Fleming Island
CrimeGrade rates Fleming Island overall A+, and AreaVibes reports crime rates 57% lower than the Florida average, with a crime grade of A. On both sources, this is the strongest safety profile in Clay County.
Military, First Responders and Police
Some 4,092 veterans live here — an outsized veteran footprint for a community this size. The drive is about 25–35 minutes to NAS Jacksonville and about 60–75 minutes to Naval Station Mayport (estimates). This is a NAS-first community, and the veteran concentration skews toward retirees and officers. First responders and law enforcement families are drawn by the same schools + safety combination. If you are moving on orders, start with our PCS relocation guide and the Clay County mortgage broker page. Check what your allowance will cover with the Military BAH Calculator.
Homes and Housing Stock
The housing fabric is master-planned — Eagle Harbor, Margaret’s Walk, Pace Island — with golf, pools, trails, and river and marsh frontage. HOA + CDD fees are the norm, Doctors Lake waterfront is the premium tier, and the island is largely built out, so new supply is infill only.
Get the Fleming Island Buyer Brief
Get new listings that fit your budget, the payment breakdown on the $475,000 median home, and the HOA+CDD questions to ask before offering — from Douglas Wilkerson, Mortgage Broker, (904) 517-4049.
Frequently Asked Questions About Fleming Island
Why is Fleming Island more expensive?
The single-family median is $475,000 (Q1 2026) at $210 per square foot, with 48 days on market and about 97% list-to-sale; the median listing was $489,000 (Realtor.com, Sep 2026). You are paying for Clay County’s best public schools, Eagle Harbor amenities, master-planned streets, and built-out scarcity — there is very little new supply left on the island.
Are the schools really the best in Clay County?
By the ratings, yes: Robert M. Paterson Elementary is 10/10, Fleming Island Elementary 9/10, and Thunderbolt Elementary 8/10. Fleming Island High School is 7–8/10 with a Niche grade of A (fih.oneclay.net). Junior-high zoning varies by address — Lakeside Junior High (7/10) serves part of the island — so confirm zoning for any specific home.
What do HOA and CDD fees add each month?
HOA + CDD fees are the norm in the planned communities, and they stack on top of the tax bill. Property tax in ZIP 32003 runs about 1.14% effective (Ownwell) — the highest in Clay County, consistent with newer, higher-value stock. Price both the fees and the tax rate into any comparison before you offer.
How is the commute to NAS Jacksonville?
About 25–35 minutes to NAS Jacksonville and about 60–75 minutes to Naval Station Mayport (estimates). Fleming Island is a NAS-first community — 4,092 veterans live here — and the commute is the main trade for the schools and safety.
Is Fleming Island safe?
CrimeGrade rates Fleming Island overall A+, and AreaVibes reports crime rates 57% lower than the Florida average, with a crime grade of A. On both sources, this is the strongest safety profile in Clay County.
Is Doctors Lake waterfront worth the premium?
Waterfront is the premium tier on the island, but it trades thin and slow — typically 90–150 days — so do not expect a quick resale. Also budget for the insurance wall: 4-point and wind-mitigation inspections are standard on pre-2002 homes, and older waterfront stock can carry real insurance costs.
Equal Housing Opportunity. Mortgage services are provided by Douglas Wilkerson, Branch Manager and Mortgage Broker with Edge Home Finance Corporation. Loan programs, rates, eligibility, underwriting guidelines and availability are subject to change. All applications are subject to credit review, verification, property eligibility, applicable underwriting requirements and final approval. This website does not constitute a commitment to lend or a guarantee of financing.